Last week
we introduced the Needle Mixture Meter - a simple, cost effective and easy way
of watching the real-time output of your car's oxygen sensor. This week, it's
time to install it.
We decided to mount the
Needle Mixture Meter directly in front of the driver, sitting on top of the
steering column cover. A small bracket was made from aluminium, bent into a
right angle. This held the display at the correct angle for best viewing by the
driver, while at the same time not letting the meter obscure any of the normal
instruments. The location also gave plenty of space in front of the meter to
mount the two tiny illumination LEDs, which were concealed within a small
housing made from half of a TV aerial balun cover. (Basically, any small black piece
of plastic with the right shape can be used as a housing.) We used two very
small LEDs, but a single larger LED will also work.
Note that when you buy the
LED(s) - any size, from 3mm to 10mm - you will also need to purchase a 560-ohm
resistor to limit the current flow thru them. Price for both the resistor and a
LED from an electronics store will be under 50 cents. Note also that the long
leg of the LED is the one you connect to positive 12 volts - put the resistor
in this leg to make it even longer! I chose to use two 3mm LEDs, wired in
parallel while still using just the one current limiting resistor.
Alternatively, you can just buy a small 12 volt lamp - hobby stores sell tiny
ones that are used in model railways and the like. Then you don't need to worry
about a resistor or getting the polarity right.
Anyway, our installation
used orange LEDs to match the orange instrumentation lighting being used in my
Audi. The LEDs were powered from the same supply as the Needle Mixture Meter.
This means that whenever the car is running, they are on - not a problem since
the life of the LEDs is likely to be longer than the car.
The Audi
has a 3-wire oxygen sensor - earth, a 12V supply for its internal heater, and a
signal output wire. I decided to power the Needle Mixture Meter directly from
the oxygen sensor - since I already needed to have one wire (the signal)
connecting the oxy sensor to the meter, why not have three wires (signal,
power, earth)? In turn I bared each of the three wires leading the oxy sensor,
soldering an insulated wire to each. Note that close up to the oxy sensor often
the wires are made from stainless steel rather than copper, with the stainless
being quite hard to solder to. There are two ways of overcoming this - tap into
the oxy sensor wires closer to the ECU, or use a crimp style connection to the
oxy sensor wires.
I didn't even bother to
work out which wire was which at this stage - I just made my connections,
insulated the joins, and ran the new wires back into the cabin. Then, using a
multimeter, I worked out which was the earth, the signal and the positive 12V
supply wires. The earth connects to the Needle Mixture Meter's black wire, the
positive 12V to the Needle Mixture Meter's red wire, and the oxy sensor signal
goes to the Needle Mixture Meter's white wire. Easy - but don't get them the
wrong way around!
(Just a minor warning note.
On some cars the oxygen sensor heater may turn off when the sensor is up to
temp. If you are powering the meter from the oxygen sensor's heater and you
find that your Needle Mixture Meter suddenly goes off after a few minutes of
running but comes back on again at the next restart - it may be that the heater
switches itself off. However, cars that take this approach are very rare.)
I once read
a post in a discussion group from someone who thought that the output of an
oxygen sensor was a constantly varying voltage. Like, the volts went up and
down because that's the way the sensor worked. Wrong!
However, if
you didn't know what to look for, you could be easily convinced that the output
of the oxy sensor on a factory EFI car is almost random. But it ain't.
Sure,
sometimes you'll see the needle flicking back and forth - quite often actually
- but that's because the air/fuel ratio is actually also going up and down -
rich, lean, rich, lean. It's doing this the whole time that you're in closed
loop - that is, when the oxygen sensor is feeding information back to the ECU
and the ECU is actually paying attention to it.
So by
watching the Needle Mixture Meter, you can immediately see at what loads and
speeds your car works in closed loop. Note that even expensive tail-pipe probe
air/fuel ratio meters can't see the alternating mixtures as well as the Needle
Mixture Meter.
So why
would you care if your car is in closed loop? Here are two reasons:
·
Modifications made to the mixtures by using an interceptor
module or changing fuel pressure will not be retained when your car is
in closed loop. That is, closed loop mods will be subsequently "learned
out". Now if your car is still in closed loop at a fairly high load (and
that's the case with some cars), then it's only at higher loads than
this that these types of tuning changes will be retained. So when your friendly
workshop tells you how they've made your car more economical by using an
interceptor to lean the mixtures when you're cruising at 100 km/h, you can say
"Crap, it's still in closed loop at 100." And watch their jaws
drop...
·
If the oxygen sensor is getting tired, the voltage
oscillations (the speed of the needle movement) will be slow. If the oxy
sensor's dead - the needle won't move ever. Some cars will have the needle a
flickering blur in closed loop, so quickly are the mixtures changing back and
forth.
So what will happen on the
display when you first start the car? Firstly, in some cars, the meter needle
with stay at the full lefthand position until the oxy sensor warms up. (On
other cars a bias voltage is applied, resulting in the needle immediately
jumping to about the middle.). Then, as the sensor gets hot, the needle will
become active. Soon it will be flicking back and forth across the scale,
showing that you're in closed loop. Give the engine a burst of throttle, and
you'll see the needle jump across to the right as the mixtures go richer in
response to the throttle input. Then, on the overrun, the needle will go full
left (lean) as the injectors shut off.
So, not only can you
monitor closed loop behaviour, you can also see a heap of other things:
·
Rich warm-up mixtures
·
Rich full-load mixtures
·
Ultra-lean trailing throttle mixtures
·
And, perhaps, lean cruise mixtures (None of my cars have
ever had a lean cruise ECU function, so I can't be certain that you'd be able
to see it. But I think that you would!)
If you are
running your car on programmable management, you will still be able to see the
range of mixtures that is being used - although the closed loop fluctuations
usually won't happen as closed-loop programmable ECUs are rare. To reiterate a
point made earlier, the Needle Mixture Meter is not sufficiently
accurate to allow you to do full load tuning, but it will certainly give you a
very useful real time guide as to what is going on.
Once you've
driven around with the Needle Mixture Meter telling its flickering tale, it's
very hard to go back to having no mixture indication. And I tell you one thing
- if, after you've fitted the display, you're driving along and the engine
stumbles or develops a flat spot, I bet of all your gauges it's the Needle
Mixture Meter that you'll look at first...
Through
the AutoSpeed
Shop the EMA 1710 Needle Mixture Meter costs AUD$78, plus $7 freight within
Australia. (For overseas shipping rates, add the item to your shopping cart and
change the country drop down box.)